Lipstick on a pig: What the new 401(k) “Democratization” really means


First time seeing? Sign up here

October 8, 2025 | Read Online

Morning,

Real estate sponsors should care about the recent private equity Executive Order (EO) because it signals how capital markets are shifting – and what investors will be seeing next.

On August 7, after lobbying by private equity mega-firms like Blackstone, KKR, Apollo, and Carlyle, the White House signed an Executive Order directing regulators to “expand access to alternative investments” – including private equity, hedge funds, and real estate – within 401(k) retirement plans.

The headlines called it “democratization.”

The reality is closer to risk transfer – from sophisticated institutions that no longer want to hold these assets, to retail savers who don’t understand what they’re buying.


How Private Equity Got Here

For decades, private equity (PE) operated on a clean, predictable cycle:

  1. Raise capital from pensions, endowments, and sovereign funds.
  2. Buy underperforming companies, apply leverage, cut costs, and grow earnings.
  3. Exit by selling to a strategic buyer or taking the company public through an IPO.

At its best, it looked like capitalism’s finest hour: disciplined operators improving businesses and delivering 20%+ annualized returns.

But that heroic story depended on two things that no longer exist – cheap debt and reliable exits.

The Clog: Exits Dried Up

In the past few years, the IPO market has effectively seized up. According to Bain and Apollo, nearly half of private equity’s exits now occur through sales to other private equity firms, not public offerings.

The numbers tell the story:

  • In 1999, the median company going public was 5 years old.
  • Today, it’s 14 years old – companies are staying private longer, more leveraged, and more exhausted by the time they reach public markets.

With strategic buyers cautious and higher interest rates killing the math on leveraged buyouts, PE firms found themselves stuck holding aging assets they couldn’t sell.

The Workaround: Pass the Parcel

What happened next was a form of financial cannibalism.

PE firms began selling assets to each other – or even to themselves.

Through vehicles called “continuation funds,” managers shifted old portfolio companies from one of their funds into another, often at valuations they themselves set.

This “pass the parcel” game kept fee income flowing and paper valuations high, but little actual cash returned to investors.

In short, these continuation funds and secondaries kept the fee machine moving even as true cash returns lagged.

It’s accounting theater dressed up as liquidity.

The Real Problem: Trapped Capital

By 2020–2021, record sums had been raised at near-zero interest rates. When rates jumped to 5%, those assets, underwritten for a world that no longer existed, looked fragile.

Institutional investors noticed.

  • Distributions slowed.
  • Valuations looked suspiciously smooth.
  • Subscription lines and creative financing blurred where leverage really sat.

The confidence that had fueled two decades of growth began to waver.

Fundraising slowed, and institutional limited partners (LPs) started demanding real distributions before committing new money.

Private equity’s biggest players had a problem: too much trapped capital, too few exits, and growing skepticism from their traditional backers.

The Solution: Tap Retail

Enter “democratization.”

If institutions were reluctant to re-up, the obvious next move was to find new money. And there’s no bigger pool than the $8–10 trillion sitting in U.S. 401(k) plans.

After years of industry lobbying, the August 7 Executive Order opened the regulatory door for retirement plans to include alternatives like private equity, hedge funds, and private real estate.

It’s marketed as “leveling the playing field” by giving ordinary savers access to the same “sophisticated” investments as pensions and endowments.

But the timing tells you everything:

  • Exits are clogged.
  • Fundraising has slowed.
  • And now, retail investors are being invited to help the pros get liquid.

The Business of Banking — 1925 Meets 2025

This isn’t new. A century ago, during the 1920s boom, investment banks recycled securities through syndicates, passing risk downstream to retail investors while keeping the best tranches for themselves.

The system worked until confidence cracked. When prices fell, the structure collapsed, amplifying the Great Depression.

Today’s private equity continuation funds are the modern equivalent of those syndicate pools:

  • Illiquid assets get repackaged as opportunity.
  • Risk is dressed up in the brand polish of household names.
  • And retail investors – now through their 401(k)s – become the exit liquidity for the industry’s oldest and least desirable assets.

The lipstick is the marketing veneer: “private equity,” “institutional-grade,” “alternative access.”

The pig is what’s underneath: levered, aging, overpriced companies that can’t find a real buyer.

The Mechanism of “Democratization”

So how does this actually work?

401(k) plans won’t suddenly start buying stakes in random private equity funds.

Instead, asset managers like Blackstone, Apollo, and KKR will create multi-layered investment vehicles – think funds-of-funds or target-date portfolios – that include private equity slices within otherwise familiar mutual fund or ETF wrappers.

The goal isn’t transparency; it’s scale.

Each intermediary adds another layer of fees and opacity, but the retail-facing presentation looks simple:

“Your retirement plan now includes exposure to institutional-grade private markets.”

In truth, the capital flows up the chain, freeing large PE funds from positions they can’t otherwise unload.

Why This Matters to CRE Sponsors

For commercial real estate professionals raising capital, this isn’t an abstract policy shift. It directly affects how your prospective investors think, compare, and allocate.

Here’s what it means – and what it doesn’t.

What it means:

  • Your investors will start seeing “private real estate” funds marketed inside their 401(k) accounts, packaged by mega-firms with institutional polish.
  • The bar for professionalism and reporting just rose: investors will expect the same standard of communication and digital access from you.
  • The narrative of “private access” will grow louder. You’ll need to counter it with the substance of transparency, clarity, and real relationships.

What it doesn’t mean:

  • 401(k) capital will not flow into your deals. These products are designed for billion-dollar structures, not sponsor-level syndications.
  • You’re not competing for 401(k) allocations, you’re competing for attention. The “private real estate” story will now be told by firms with marketing machines bigger than most sponsors’ entire organizations.

The Takeaway

Private equity’s pivot toward retail is a symptom of strain, not strength.

The industry’s liquidity engine broke, and 401(k) investors are the new replacement parts.

For private equity firms, it buys time.

For retail savers, it introduces risk they can’t price.

And for real estate sponsors, it’s a signal: the fight for investor mindshare is about to get louder, slicker, and even more confusing than it already is.

The winners won’t be those with the biggest platforms. They’ll be the ones who look institutional but act personal, combining professional polish with transparent, trustworthy communication.

Because while mega-funds may control the headlines, they can’t replace the one thing that still moves real money: relationship-driven trust.

***

This is the work we do with multi-cycle sponsors who want to attract more investors and raise more capital by elevating their visibility and authority in a crowded marketplace. Reply to this email and I’ll share a few ways you can stand out - especially now that the latest “democratization” story has changed the landscape.

***

If you found today's newsletter thought provoking, please join the conversation on LinkedIn. I posted a shorter, less detailed version this morning.

Join the conversation here >>

Adam

​If this is your first time seeing this newsletter, please click here to subscribe.

***

Connect with me on LinkedIn

Subscribe to my YouTube channel

Please note that I am not an investment advisor or attorney and do not make investment recommendations of any kind. Please seek advice from your financial advisor, accountant, attorney, and any other professional in assessing the risks associated with any investment opportunity, as every opportunity has risks that could result in a substantial loss.

If you no longer wish to receive any of our emails [gasp], please click this link: Unsubscribe or here to Update your profile | Dr. Adam Gower 324 S Beverly Drive, Suite 501, Beverly Hills, CA 90212

The GowerCrowd Newsletter

Real estate markets move in cycles, and understanding history is the key to navigating today’s opportunities. As a seasoned investor with 30+ years in the industry, I take a historically informed, risk-averse approach—where capital preservation is the priority. You'll get market insights and investment strategies tailored to both passive investors and capital raisers, with a particular focus on raising private capital. Occasionally, I also share best practices in digital lead generation on LinkedIn and using AI to optimize lead generation. I also introduce my latest podcast and YouTube series, where you'll hear from capital allocators, unpacking trends, strategies, and the future of real estate capital formation. For those looking to invest smarter, raise capital more effectively, and stay ahead of market shifts, The GowerCrowd Newsletter offers a concise yet detailed perspective on the forces shaping our industry.

Read more from The GowerCrowd Newsletter
A rolling loan gathers no loss

First time seeing? Sign up here October 29, 2025 | Read Online Morning,You can time the market. Yes, you heard that right. The prevailing orthodoxy insists you can’t. The practice of “buy and hold through thick and thin” dominates. But what if the smarter play is acknowledging that yes, you can time markets, provided you recognize where valuations are extreme, where they are depressed, and act accordingly? The folly and the possibility Most investment counsel treats market timing as a fool’s...

A banquet of consequences

First time seeing? Sign up here October 21, 2025 | Read Online Morning,Washington is about to open the floodgates.New research from Alvarez & Marsal estimates that a planned rollback of post-2008 “Basel III endgame” capital rules by U.S. financial regulatory authorities, the framework that forced banks to hold more loss-absorbing equity, will unlock $2.6 trillion in new lending capacity and free nearly $140 billion in capital for Wall Street’s biggest lenders.The proposals would scale back...

First time seeing? Sign up here October 14, 2025 | Read Online Morning,Every cycle has its moment of euphoria, a period when policy, liquidity, and sentiment all point in the same direction, and capital flows as though gravity has been suspended. That moment is now approaching again. In Washington, the tone of regulation has shifted decisively. The planned rollback of post-2008 “Basel III endgame” capital rules – the very framework designed to prevent another financial crisis – will soon free...